|
"A
Strategy to win with only six Controlled Areas"
Did you know that 0.7
= 1.0 in BKN mathematics? It's stated in Rule 22.4, but somehow
this important fact doesn't get much attention. It means the Allies
can win the one-week scenario by controlling only six relatively-easy-to-conquer
Areas, provided they hold the Advantage at the end of the game and
also contest Areas worth 13 Victory Points. Getting control of bocage
Areas is usually hard to do, much harder than merely contesting
them, so this strategy is worthy of serious consideration. Here's
a way to implement this plan of attack.
First, the Allies must
gain 6 VPs by controlling the five 'easy' Areas: Bayeux (2), Ste.
Mère-Église (1), Isigny (1), Catz (1) and Merville
(1). Of course, these Areas are not always easy to take. For example,
if the Germans snatch the 'magic bridge' on June 6, the Allies may
never find the means to conquer Ste. Mère Église.
However, in that event the Allies will probably be directing much
more force and using many more impulses in the vicinity of Omaha
Beach -- there are always compensations. In most games though, it
should be quite feasible to take control of the five Areas just
mentioned.
The Allies need to control
one more Area and it might be any one of Tilly (1), Villars-Bocage
(1), Pont l'Abbé (1), Caumont (1), St. Vaast-la-Hougue (1),
Forest de Cerisy(1) or Valognes (1). These Areas are all rather
difficult to wrench from the Germans, but usually fortune will open
one of them to successful assault. This brings the VP total up to
7.
Retaining the advantage
at game's end -- again not necessarily an easy thing to do, but
one that is quite feasible in a good percentage of games -- gets
the Allies up to 8 VPs.
Now, to gain the remaining
1.6 VPs the Allies must contest Areas worth 13 VPs. The big VP Areas
Caen (4), St. Lo(2) and Carentan (2) will almost certainly be on
the list. They are to tough to get control of, but not so tough
to contest. In addition, Pont l'Abbe (1) is contested by the paratroops
on D-Day and with luck will continue to be contested by them at
game's end. Forest de Cerisy (1) is a good candidate to be contested,
or possibly even controlled, since it can be surrounded. That leaves
three more VPs to be contested and they can be gained in Villars-Bocage
(1), Caumont (1), St. Vaast-la-Hougue (1), Tilly (1) or Valognes
(1). Bourguebus (1) and Potigny (1) may be candidates as well, in
some games, although the prudent Allied player usually steers clear
of them. Aunay sur Odon (2) may also be a possibility if Villars-bocage
is under control.
This strategy strikes
me as quite a good one. Its great advantage is that the Allies need
to control only 6 Areas. Achieving control of that
9th VP is what's difficult in this game, since an experienced German
will certainly use an attrition strategy to hang on to the bocage
Areas, Caen and Carentan quite tenaciously. Contesting 1.6
VPs is a more realistic strategy, especially since 0.7 = 1.0 in
the mathematics of BKN.
|